January 27, 2014 (www.investorideas.com newswire) Bloomberg disclosed information about Pacific Rubiales and cited Ms. Ana Maria Silva, Head of Mining and Energy at the local Comptroller’s office. According to the source, she visited Quifa oil field to evaluate the STAR project and initial results would indicate that the project is tracking below a threshold for additional recovery rates set by state-controlled Ecopetrol SA. We expect an official statement by the Government, Ecopetrol, or any other local entity to confirm or deny these allegations. As of now, we reiterate that our rating and T.P on the stock has not changed but will be revised if the news is confirmed.
In addition to the news, we spoke to Ms. Silva, who didn’t provide any financial nor operational figures, but mentioned that the project´s reality is far less positive than what Pacific Rubiales has communicated in its financial results and press releases.
Pacific Rubiales sent an official note to market participants, where it denied all of these allegations and reiterated that the STAR technology is one of the most successful initiatives around the globe in terms of oil production recovery. In addition, three independent companies with an expertise on the industry have certified that STAR has duplicated recovery factors in Quifa. The company also denied any explosions in the oil field while testing the STAR project. Finally, Pacific mentioned that it is constantly reporting the project´s results to the Minister of Energy and to Pacific’s partner, Ecopetrol.
The news adds more uncertainty to Pacific’s shares in the market, but for us it is also uncertain whether or not this information is true. That said, we decided to draw initial conclusions regarding this issue and wait for more official information. Once again, we reiterate that our rating and T.P. will be revised if the government or Ecopetrol confirm the news.
Our T.P. COP 56,060/share is based on a DCF model with a discount rate of 13% (USD WACC); g was set at 2.0% has an implicit 2014 EV/EBITDA of 3.16x, P/E of 8.50x and P/B of 1.74x, well below PREC’s historical range and those of it’s peers. Both, total expected return and relative valuation, lead us to set a BUY rating.
Initial conclusions regarding the allegations against the STAR technology
Our valuation does not place any weight to the STAR project as it is still uncertain if it will provide positive results and will be fully applicable to producing blocks. In addition, we believe that the vast majority of market analysts do not include this project in their valuations. However, a failure or a lack of transparency in the STAR project will add more downside risk to the share’s price, as clearly demonstrated in Friday’s session (it lost 2.88%). In addition, Pacific´s chances to extend Rubiales contract with Ecopetrol will drop significantly, if not disappear entirely.
We expect an official statement by the Government, Ecopetrol or even by the ANLA to confirm or deny these allegations. As of now, we still believe this could be only a rumor that was officially denied by Pacific.
If the news is confirmed by local authorities (worst-case scenario for Pacific Rubiales), this could represent a major negative inflection point for the company. In other words, should authorities deem Pacific’s press releases and guidance regarding STAR, as false or misleading, this could undermine the public’s confidence even further, and support the market’s negative perception about the management’s delivery (reflected in the share price vs. analyst consensus TPs).
Finally, we reiterate that our rating and T.P. on the stock has not changed (PREC CB: Buy; T.P.: COP 56,060/share). However, in light of the news we recommend to be cautious and keep away from the stock in the short term or at least until more information is known. Both Target Price and Recommendation will be revised if the news is confirmed by local authorities.
Regards, Research Team
This report is property of IM Trust S.A. and/or Credicorp Capital Colombia S.A. Sociedad Comisionista de Bolsa and/or Credicorp Capital Perú S.A.A. and/or its subsidiaries (hereinafter jointly referred to as “Credicorp Capital”), therefore, no part of this the material or its content, nor any copy of it, may be altered in any way, transmitted, copied or distributed to any third party without prior and express written consent of Credicorp Capital.
In making this report, Credicorp Capital has relied on public information. Credicorp Capital has not verified the truthfulness, completeness or accuracy of the information accessed, nor has audited the information in any way. Accordingly, this report does not constitute a statement, assertion or guarantee (express or implied) as to the truth, accuracy or completeness of the information contained herein or any other written or oral information furnished to any person and/or their advisors.
Unless otherwise stated, the information used in this report is not confidential, nor constitutes privileged information that may mean the violation of the rules of the stock market, or that could mean failure to comply with copyright legislation.
This report is not intended and shall not be understood in any way as to: a) predict the future or guarantee a specific financial result; b) ensure the fulfillment of the scenarios described in it; c) be an investment advice or opinion that could be considered as Credicorp Capital recommendations.
The information contained in this report is only for referential purposes. While reading it, you should consider that the information contained in this report may be oriented to a specific segment of clients or investors, with a certain risk profile that may not be yours.
Unless otherwise stated, this report does not contain investment recommendations or other suggestions that may be understood to be given under the stock market intermediaries’ special duty to clients classified as investors. When recommendations are made, the report will clearly specify the investors risk profile to which the recommendation is intended. Credicorp Capital can seek and/or conduct business with companies that are mentioned in the report, and they can also execute buying and selling transactions of shares that are mentioned.
It is important to state that the fluctuation in exchange rates can have adverse effects on investments values.
It is client responsibility to determine how to use the information contained in this report. Hence, the client is the sole responsible for investment decisions or any other operation he/she might perform in the stock market based on this report. In other words, the investment or operation result made by the client using the information contained in this report is of her/his sole responsibility. Credicorp Capital does not assume any responsibility, obligation or duty for any action or omission derived from the use of this document.
Credicorp Capital recommends to their clients to ask for professional advice from financial, legal, accounting, tax experts before adopting an investment decision. Under no circumstances the information contained in this report may be considered as a financial, legal, accounting or taxation opinion, neither as a recommendation or investment advice.
Published at the Investorideas.com Newswire - Big ideas for Global Investors
Disclaimer/ Disclosure:The Investorideas.com newswire is a third party publisher of news and research as well as creates original content as a news source. Original content created by investorideas is protected by copyright laws other than syndication rights. Investorideas is a news source on Google news and Linkedintoday plus hundreds of syndication partners. Our site does not make recommendations for purchases or sale of stocks or products. Nothing on our sites should be construed as an offer or solicitation to buy or sell products or securities. All investment involves risk and possible loss of investment. This site is currently compensated by featured companies, news submissions, content marketing and online advertising. Contact each company directly for press release questions. Disclosure is posted on each release if required but otherwise the news was not compensated for and is published for the sole interest of our readers. More disclaimer info: http://www.investorideas.com/About/Disclaimer.asp
BC Residents and Investor Disclaimer : Effective September 15 2008 - all BC investors should review all OTC and Pink sheet listed companies for adherence in new disclosure filings and filing appropriate documents with Sedar. Read for more info: http://www.bcsc.bc.ca/release.aspx?id=6894. Global investors must adhere to regulations of each country.